graph TD
    %% Main predicates with their status
    P1169["Predicate 1169 (Withdrawn)<br>Bringing manufacturing jobs back + tariffs<br>could create employment"]
    P1175["Predicate 1175 (Withdrawn)<br>Bringing manufacturing jobs back<br>could create employment"]
    P1406["Predicate 1406 (Unchallenged)<br>Automation will limit employment gains<br>from reshoring manufacturing"]
    P1411["Predicate 1411<br>Franklin withdraws his argument<br>based on evidence and ratings"]
    
    %% Supporting evidence
    DOC5[/"Document 5<br>Why Reshoring is the Future"/]
    DOC6[/"Document 6<br>Manufacturing Jobs Aren't Coming Back"/]
    DOC7[/"Document 7<br>Tariffs Will Reduce US GDP"/]
    
    %% Ratings summary
    R1169["Ratings for P1169<br>Average: 28, Median: 20<br>(Lower agreement)"]
    R1406["Ratings for P1406<br>Average: 62.5, Median: 72.5<br>(Higher agreement)"]
    
    %% Relationships between predicates
    P1175 -->|"component of"| P1169
    P1406 -->|"counter to"| P1169
    P1406 -->|"counter to"| P1175
    P1411 -->|"withdrawal of"| P1169
    P1411 -->|"withdrawal of"| P1175
    
    %% Document connections
    DOC5 -->|"supports"| P1169
    DOC5 -->|"supports"| P1175
    DOC6 -->|"supports"| P1406
    DOC7 -->|"supports"| P1406
    
    %% Rating connections
    R1169 -->|"rated"| P1169
    R1406 -->|"rated"| P1406
    
    %% Influences in the debate
    DOC6 -.->|"influenced"| P1411
    DOC7 -.->|"influenced"| P1411
    R1406 -.->|"influenced"| P1411
    
    %% Styling
    classDef withdrawn fill:#ffcccc,stroke:#ff0000,color:black
    classDef unchallenged fill:#ccffcc,stroke:#00cc00,color:black
    classDef withdrawal fill:#ffffcc,stroke:#cccc00,color:black
    classDef document fill:#e0f7fa,stroke:#00acc1,color:black
    classDef rating fill:#f3e5f5,stroke:#8e24aa,color:black
    
    class P1169,P1175 withdrawn
    class P1406 unchallenged
    class P1411 withdrawal
    class DOC5,DOC6,DOC7 document
    class R1169,R1406 rating